by Deborah Lee, and Michael Frett of Naturalake Biosciences Laboratories
Pithophora is a common filamentous green alga that is found in a variety of water resources. It can often be problematic and is difficult to treat and control. Pithophora blooms form dense mat structures and have thick cell walls that limit algaecide penetration and efficacy. In addition, the cells can often be coated in carbonate crystals or attached diatoms that further reduce penetration and efficacy of algaecide treatments. Pithophora also forms resting structures called akinetes. The structures are packed with food reserves and have thicker cell walls that allow for survival when conditions become unfavorable. These structures also allow for rapid regrowth of vegetative filaments when favorable conditions return
Improving algaecide efficacy through improving the absorption and the degradation of dead akinetes was the focus in the development of PondZilla Pro. PondZilla Pro is a biocatalyst that is designed to be mixed with algaecides when treating Pithophora. It does not kill or damage Pithophora on its own. Increasing the amount of algaecide that penetrates the akinetes should result in enhanced control of the Pithophora. More complete degradation of the dead resting structures that aid in regrowth should result in enhanced control of Pithophora. Visual observations in laboratory tests and field tests have reported increased damage to Pithophora filaments and longer-lasting control when algaecides were mixed with PondZilla Pro. To better quantify the impact of PondZilla Pro, a controlled laboratory experiment was designed to measure the change in damage to filaments and overall reduction in biomass attributed to the addition of PondZilla Pro.
To measure how the addition of PondZilla Pro effects treatment efficacy of Pithophora when combined with copper algaecides.
9oz clear plastic cups were labeled and mass was recorded. The pond water from a Madison, WI pond was collected filtered through a 0.45um pore filter before freezing. The filtered water was thawed and used to make 1:8 SD11 media. The cups were filled with 200ml each of the 1:8 SD11 media. Pieces of Pithophora were blotted on paper towels to remove excess water. 0.100g±0.003g of green Pithophora was added to each cup. The mass of the cups with media and algae were recorded. Products were added to 1ml of water removed from the cup of corresponding number, products were added, the mixture was resuspended five times to mix and added to the corresponding cup in a dropwise manner randomly across the surface of the cup. The cups were photographed and then placed on a Vivosun heat mat controlled by a Vivosun controller set to 85°F. The tops of the cups were about 14 inches under the T4 cool fluorescent (6w) grow light. The lights were on a 12h:12h light:dark cycle. To prevent excessive evaporation, the cups were covered loosely with plastic wrap. Every day for the 10 day test period, the cups were uncovered, photographed and 20ml of media was exchanged with fresh media. At the end of the test period, the cups were drained of most of the media and placed uncovered back on the mat. The liquid in the cups was evaporated for seven days before the final mass of the cups containing dry algae was recorded. Dry algal biomass was determined by subtracting the final cup and algal mass from a sacrificial set prepared initially.
Table of Treatments
0 Days After Treatment
Treated algae placed on heat mat in lab under grow light. Left column has cups number 1, 2, 3, then going by column to the right are cups 4, 5, 6, then next right column are cups 7, 8, 9, etc. Sacrifice 25, 26, 27 (far right) right after treated algae were placed on heat mat. Sacrificed cups were left on heat mat for seven days before final dry mass of algae was determined. All cups started with dark green clumps of Pithophora to a mass of 0.100 ± 0.003g.
Post Treatment Visual Analysis
Both the PondZilla Pro alone and untreated control resulted in increased biomass after 10 DAT. All copper algaecides resulted in a slight decrease in Pithophora biomass after 10 DAT. All copper algaecides with PondZilla Pro resulted in decreased biomass compared to the untreated control, PondZilla Pro alone and algaecide alone treatment samples.
Only algaecide with PondZilla Pro treated samples show visible cellular damage at 7 DAT. AT 10 DAT, algaecide samples with PondZilla Pro showed significantly more visible cellular damage compared to algaecide samples without PondZilla Pro.
In this study, it is shown that PondZilla Pro alone does not damage or kill the green filamentous algae, Pithophora. Copper algaecides alone were effective at providing some level of control and reducing the biomass of Pithophora. Copper algaecides improved response time, overall control, and reduced more biomass when combined with PondZilla Pro. PondZilla Pro can be used as an effective biocatalyst to improve treatments of Pithophora with copper algaecides.